Disclaimer: I am not writing this blog, "My Keypad" is doing so. So trolls, I want no hounding whatsoever.
The recent furore in the social media over a video gone viral of a 20 year old DU student invited my attention. Such was the controversy that, there were even talks of the girl being influenced by some "anti national" elements. My curiosity led me to research about the girl and her video. I took to google. To my amazement I found a page full of news reports,articles, blogs,open letters and even a Wikipedia page dedicated to her. I found that the girl is already a celebrity by now. But my research proved to give me futile results, as all these reading materials available on the internet failed to provide a clear picture of the events. So I finally took to YouTube to look for myself the real unedited version of the video.
I found the video on a channel named " Voice Of Ram" run by Ram Subramanium, an ad film maker who started an online campaign named " Profile for Peace" a year ago.The video which was titled "Soldier of peace" dates back to 2016. That's almost a year ago. The campaign was a peace initiative between the two Nations.The video displayed a young girl displaying some messages on placards one after the other. The messages were plain and simple. It was an emotional confession and an appeal for peace from a girl who had experienced a personal loss from the War. After all who can better feel the pain,agony,horrors of War and realize it's perils than the loved ones of those martyred.
The point to be noticed here is that a snapshot of only one statement out of a series of statements contained in the video which read " Pakistan Did not Kill my dad, War Killed him" was circulated all over the internet.The rest of the girl's silent speech went totally unnoticed. Can you smell some selective targeting here? The placard that created all the furore was obviously not a stand alone statement, but a part of the series of statements which actually constitute an emotional peace appeal.Now what on world is " Anti National" about that? If you ask me, war mongering and jingoism is "Anti National" as it advocates deploying and diverting a nation's resources,wealth and time towards war. It effects the Nation's health.
Coming back to the controversy, lets examine as to how did the video resurface just in the middle of a campus brawl between two rival student outfits? The answer lies in the fact that the young girl was part of the Save DU campaign run by one of the two outfits.The campaign was a protest against the violence perpetrated in the campus by the other outfit. Upon sensing the online campaign gaining strength and garnering ample support, the trolls got to work. They mined some data from the social media and selectively identified some excerpts from the video that could be used as a targeting tool against her. These excerpts were then circulated all over the internet. What followed was an orchestrated hate campaign on the social media.Though the troll campaign was masqueraded as an effort to silence the 20 year old "Anti National" girl, it appears there were some ulterior motives. One of them could be to divert the public attention from the on going violence and ruckus created at the DU North campus.
Now let us examine the political undertones of the messages in the video. Talks of peace and war mongering have been going hand in hand since the last 70 years now between the two Nations.It has always been a "Love-Hate" relationship. I admit that jingoism and war mongering has fetched a lot of votes for political parties in both the nations, but peace is not an easy option.Let us also acknowledge that there has been a good amount of sincere efforts put forth by past and present governments on this front. But the reason we still do not have a solution are some lingering issues which needs to be settled first. Diplomacy isn't a cake walk.
Nonetheless I would not like to enter into the ceaseless "Anti National Vs Patriotism" debate as of now. All I want form "You Trolls" is to first get a proper job and help build your nation instead of just creating brouhaha over everything that seems remotely in opposition to your opinion and perception of things. And if for some strong reasons you have a craving for creating a ruckus everywhere, go take it all out on the streets.Let your so called " Anti- Nationals" live at peace on the social media at the least if you can't tolerate them on the streets.LET PEACE PREVAIL...
The recent furore in the social media over a video gone viral of a 20 year old DU student invited my attention. Such was the controversy that, there were even talks of the girl being influenced by some "anti national" elements. My curiosity led me to research about the girl and her video. I took to google. To my amazement I found a page full of news reports,articles, blogs,open letters and even a Wikipedia page dedicated to her. I found that the girl is already a celebrity by now. But my research proved to give me futile results, as all these reading materials available on the internet failed to provide a clear picture of the events. So I finally took to YouTube to look for myself the real unedited version of the video.
I found the video on a channel named " Voice Of Ram" run by Ram Subramanium, an ad film maker who started an online campaign named " Profile for Peace" a year ago.The video which was titled "Soldier of peace" dates back to 2016. That's almost a year ago. The campaign was a peace initiative between the two Nations.The video displayed a young girl displaying some messages on placards one after the other. The messages were plain and simple. It was an emotional confession and an appeal for peace from a girl who had experienced a personal loss from the War. After all who can better feel the pain,agony,horrors of War and realize it's perils than the loved ones of those martyred.
The point to be noticed here is that a snapshot of only one statement out of a series of statements contained in the video which read " Pakistan Did not Kill my dad, War Killed him" was circulated all over the internet.The rest of the girl's silent speech went totally unnoticed. Can you smell some selective targeting here? The placard that created all the furore was obviously not a stand alone statement, but a part of the series of statements which actually constitute an emotional peace appeal.Now what on world is " Anti National" about that? If you ask me, war mongering and jingoism is "Anti National" as it advocates deploying and diverting a nation's resources,wealth and time towards war. It effects the Nation's health.
Coming back to the controversy, lets examine as to how did the video resurface just in the middle of a campus brawl between two rival student outfits? The answer lies in the fact that the young girl was part of the Save DU campaign run by one of the two outfits.The campaign was a protest against the violence perpetrated in the campus by the other outfit. Upon sensing the online campaign gaining strength and garnering ample support, the trolls got to work. They mined some data from the social media and selectively identified some excerpts from the video that could be used as a targeting tool against her. These excerpts were then circulated all over the internet. What followed was an orchestrated hate campaign on the social media.Though the troll campaign was masqueraded as an effort to silence the 20 year old "Anti National" girl, it appears there were some ulterior motives. One of them could be to divert the public attention from the on going violence and ruckus created at the DU North campus.
Now let us examine the political undertones of the messages in the video. Talks of peace and war mongering have been going hand in hand since the last 70 years now between the two Nations.It has always been a "Love-Hate" relationship. I admit that jingoism and war mongering has fetched a lot of votes for political parties in both the nations, but peace is not an easy option.Let us also acknowledge that there has been a good amount of sincere efforts put forth by past and present governments on this front. But the reason we still do not have a solution are some lingering issues which needs to be settled first. Diplomacy isn't a cake walk.
Nonetheless I would not like to enter into the ceaseless "Anti National Vs Patriotism" debate as of now. All I want form "You Trolls" is to first get a proper job and help build your nation instead of just creating brouhaha over everything that seems remotely in opposition to your opinion and perception of things. And if for some strong reasons you have a craving for creating a ruckus everywhere, go take it all out on the streets.Let your so called " Anti- Nationals" live at peace on the social media at the least if you can't tolerate them on the streets.LET PEACE PREVAIL...